SoldPHXShortSaleAZ

Your Options — Honest Pros & Cons

Foreclosure is rarely the only option. Here are the six real paths Arizona homeowners take — what works, what doesn't, and how to choose.

Short Sale

Best when: You owe more than the home is worth and have a hardship.

Pros
  • ✓ Lender forgives the shortfall
  • ✓ Costs you $0 out of pocket
  • ✓ Credit recovers in ~2 years
  • ✓ You stay in control of the sale
Cons
  • ✗ Takes 60–120 days
  • ✗ Requires lender approval
  • ✗ Need to document hardship

Loan Modification

Best when: You want to keep the home and have stable income.

Pros
  • ✓ Lower monthly payment
  • ✓ Stay in the home
  • ✓ Avoids any sale at all
Cons
  • ✗ Requires income that supports new payment
  • ✗ Can take months and may be denied
  • ✗ Most modifications fail within 2 years if income hasn't recovered

Forbearance

Best when: Your hardship is temporary (a few months).

Pros
  • ✓ Pauses or reduces payments short-term
  • ✓ Quick to set up
Cons
  • ✗ Missed payments must be repaid later (lump sum or added to loan)
  • ✗ Doesn't solve a long-term problem

Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure

Best when: You can't sell and want out of the loan without foreclosure.

Pros
  • ✓ Avoids the public foreclosure record
  • ✓ Less harmful to credit than foreclosure
  • ✓ May include cash-for-keys
Cons
  • ✗ Lender usually requires you list the home for sale first (a short sale attempt)
  • ✗ May still owe a deficiency in some cases

Sell with Equity

Best when: Your home is worth more than you owe.

Pros
  • ✓ No foreclosure, no short sale, no lender approval
  • ✓ Walk away with cash in hand
  • ✓ Fastest option (30–45 days)
Cons
  • ✗ Requires real equity
  • ✗ Still costs you standard selling fees

Bankruptcy

Best when: You need to halt a foreclosure sale immediately or have broader debt issues.

Pros
  • ✓ Automatic stay halts the foreclosure auction
  • ✓ Chapter 13 can let you catch up over 3–5 years
Cons
  • ✗ Major credit impact (~7+ years)
  • ✗ Requires an attorney — talk to one before filing
  • ✗ Doesn't make the underlying debt go away on its own

Not sure which one fits?

Most homeowners don't — and that's normal. A 15-minute call is usually enough to know your best path.

Get a personal recommendation

Tell me about your situation — I'll tell you which option fits and why.

By submitting this form you authorize Ryan Melville to contact you by phone, text, and email about your property and options. Consent is not a condition of any service. We never share or sell your information. This site is for informational purposes and does not provide legal, tax, or financial advice.

Not sure where to start?

A 10-minute call can change everything. Free, confidential, no pressure.

Talk to a SpecialistCall 480-672-1721